Legal update spring 2018 criminal justice reform bill on april, 2018, governor baker signed s. For a retributivist, the moral responsibility of an offender also gives socie. But at the same time, matt matravers points out, philosophers have shown that the idea of responsibility is deeply problematic 10 and is likely to be challenged further by our increasingly naturalistic understanding of the world 12. Proin gravida dolor sit amet lacus accumsan et viverra justo commodo. Thus, fa accounts rely on there being some normative relation holding between the properties being explained and the relevant attitudes. Political philosophers, especially egalitarians, have responded to such developments by attempting to map out the proper place for responsibility in theories of justice. Under what conditions are people responsible for their choices and the. Topics addressed include crime and criminalization. Ronald dworkins recently published book, sovereign virtue hereafter sv, appeals to arguments that are popular within, and ideas that are fundamental to, liberal egalitarianism. English download full ebook pdf treatment for crime. Freedom and the criminal law research database, the.
However, their place in criminal justice is disputed. His previous publications include justice and punishment oup, 2000. Bibliotekernes beskrivelse in this lively and accessible book, matt matravers considers the role of responsibility in politics, morality and the law. The problem is approached by asking by what right some people punish others, and by comparing recent developments in theories of distributive and retributive justice. Desert in distributive and retributive justice1 matt matravers 6. The case of nancy mitford versus evelyn waugh ineconomics and happiness2000 political theory and the criminal law inphilosophical foundations of criminal law2000 mad, bad, or faulty. The ethical and social implications of nanotechnology, ed.
This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves. Will be a valuable resource for further study and research. This article hence proposes an alternative approach to being a responsibilitysensitive egalitarian. He is the author of justice and punishment oxford university press, 2000 and responsibility and justice polity press, 2007 as well as of numerous articles and chapters on political and legal philosophy. Responsibility and justice by matt matravers overdrive. Criminal law and philosophy fills a gap in the scholarly literature by providing a platform for articles that take a philosophical perspective on any issue in the broad field of crime and punishment. Criminal justice criminal justice system criminal responsibility strict liability side constraint these keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. The dominant orientation in both mainstream and alternative forms of criminal justice theory. How legitimate expectations matter in climate justice commentator. Matravers analyses contemporary theories of justice in an illuminating manner. The connection between egalitarianism and responsibility has been the most controversial part of the recent debate about egalitarianism.
More by matt matravers happiness and political philosophy. Working papers from the 2014 annual conference of the robina institute of criminal law and criminal justice edited by michelle madden dempsey r a duff zach hoskins neha jain this publication is a collection of papers in draft form that resulted from the robina institutes 2014 annual conference, the future of criminal law. The concept can be applied to fairness in dynamics between children, youth, adults and seniors, in terms of treatment and interactions. Victims and the clinical model of responsibility without blame nicola m. The terms luck egalitarianism, equality of fortune, and responsibilitysensitive egalitarianism are used to describe those positions that defend a prominent role for responsibility within egalitarianism. Matthew kramer, for the invitations, and to them and all the other members of these gatherings for their. Responsibility and distributive justice edited by carl knight and zofia stemplowska. Justice scalias answer endorses the retributive function of criminal law.
Matt matravers edward page benefiting from climatic injustice commentator. He is the author of justice and punishment oxford university press, 2000 and responsibility and justice polity press, 2007 as well as of numerous articles and chapters on political and legal philosophy lukas h. He uses this to extend the debate on punishment, as well as political theory, in an original and stimulating manner. The victim, the state, and civil society 1 matt matravers crime victims are increasingly of interest to politicians, criminologists and criminal justice practitioners. His previous publications include justice and punishment oup, 2000 and responsibility within justice cup, 2006. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading responsibility and justice. Apr 23, 2018 we would like to thank andrew ashworth, david brown, cecile fabre, matt matravers, and two anonymous referees for incisive comments on an earlier version of this article, as well as christian barry for wise editorial advice. The majority of the legislation will take effect immediately, but there are portions that have staggered implementation dates.
Matravers, has also read and commented an various bits of the thesis, always bringing a depth. Anticipating the political and ethical challenges of human nanotechnologies in nanoethics. It gives readers access to the latest thinking by the fields best scholars. Matthew hannan born march 23, 1988 is an american professional wrestler, better known by his ring name, matthew justice. We can individuate fa accounts in part, therefore, by the normative. Fa responsibility and justice af matt matravers som bog pa engelsk 9780745629995 boger rummer alle sider af livet. Review of matt matravers, responsibility and justice. Responsibility and justice kindle edition by matt matravers. This book attempts to answer the challenge of showing that morality is not a confidence trick or a fetish. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Desert in distributive and retributive justice inresponsibility and distributive justice2000. Oxford university press on behalf of the mind association. Responsibility and distributive justice hardcover carl. Matt matravers is professor of politics at the university of york, uk.
Freedom and the criminal law matt matravers contemporary analytic legal and political philosophy is often highly technical. Neurointerventions in criminal justice engaging philosophy pages. Responsibility and justice ebook by matt matravers. Revisiting the hartwootton debate on responsibility. Fa responsibility and justice af matt matravers som bog pa engelsk 9780745629988 boger rummer alle sider af livet.
Such collective responsibility extends to responsibility for the national past, so the present generation may owe redress to those who have been harmed by the actions of their predecessors. Desert in distributive and retributive justice university of york. Matt matravers, political theory and the criminal law, in r. Meyer is professor of practical philosophy, university of berne. Global justice, therefore, must be understood not in terms of equality, but in terms of a minimum set of basic rights that belong to human beings everywhere. Other critics of luck equality, including martha nussbaum, elizabeth anderson, and timothy hinton. Claes lernestedt, matt matravers media of the criminal laws person. Matt matravers, responsibility and justice philpapers. In response to these arguments, dworkin has clarified his position. Matt matravers is professor of political philosophy at the university of york. We would like to thank andrew ashworth, cecile fabre, matt matravers, david brown and two. Lacey and hanna pickard abstract the dominant orientation in both mainstream and alternative forms of criminal justice theory and practice employs a single process approach.
Intergenerational equity in economic, psychological, and sociological contexts, is the concept or idea of fairness or justice between generations. It furthers the universitys objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide. Equality, responsibility, and justice carl knight responsibilitysensitive accounts of distributive justice have been a notable recent development in political theory, and luck egalitarianism has become the default position among such philosophers as ronald dworkin, g. Responsibility and distributive justice oxford scholarship. Young on responsibility and structural injustice request pdf.
Moral responsibility and merit final journal of ethics. Political theory comprehensive exam spring 2012 study guide questions. The expression far from an orthodoxy is john gardners own. Criminal justice criminal justice system criminal responsibility strict. In this lively and accessible book, matt matravers considers the role of responsibility in politics, morality and the law. It can also be applied to fairness between generations currently living and generations yet to be born. The criminal law stabilizes a public sense of justice by providing an. I follow matt matravers s analysis here matravers 2002. He asks, what are we doing when we hold people responsible in deciding questions of distributive justice or of punishment. Fa responsibility and justice af matt matravers som hardback. The victim, the state, and civil society university of york.
In recent years, responsibility has taken a central place in our lives. Original papers on key issues in political and moral philosophy. Freedom and the criminal law white rose university. It does so by arguing that moral norms are those that rational, self. This book both reflects on these recent developments in normative political theory and moves the debate forwards. The debate revolves around two positions that seek to capture the proper role for responsibility within a conception of egalitarian justice. In this lively and accessible book, matt matravers considers the highly contested role of responsibility in politics, morality, and the law.
Equality, responsibility, and justice carl knight responsibility sensitive accounts of distributive justice have been a notable recent development in political theory, and luck egalitarianism has become the default position among such philosophers as ronald dworkin, g. To receive the pdf the responsibility of the food and beverage industry for noncommunicable diseases is a controversial topic. Mar 25, 2011 33 for a more extensive discussion of the relationship of justice to punishment, see matt matravers, justice and punishment. Working papers robina institute of criminal law and. The purpose of this paper is partly to do this and to cast doubt on the adequacy of various moves made by dworkin. Within retributive justice,notions of responsibility lie at the heart of the criminal law, and popular opinion seems in general to be sensitive to issues of responsibility in a way that mirrors the distributive case. In this chapter i consider the proper roles of the state and the victim in. Matthew justice matt justice matthew busch mike stevens. These arguments and ideas need to be distinguished and unpacked. Matt matravers, however, expresses the concern of many political.
While this book does not give enough weight to utilitarian theory but who does nowadays it still manages to tackle some of the weightiest issues. Bush have claimed that individual responsibility is at the centre of their policy agendas. Fa responsibility and justice af matt matravers som paperback. Revisiting the hartwootton debate on responsibility springerlink. In this way, policy paradigms link to competing ideologies, which are systems of political thinking through which individuals and groups construct an understanding of the political and policy world. Pdf responsibility for justice, by iris marion young. In this chapter i consider the proper roles of the state and the victim in relationto criminal justice. Oxford university press is a department of the university of oxford. Criminal punishment and the pursuit of justice harvard law school. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. English download full ebook pdf treatment for crime engaging philosophy this series is a new forum for collective philosophical engagement with controversial issues in contemporary society.
178 963 1222 1433 1161 1317 956 374 553 937 67 1193 1056 921 1347 57 829 342 109 137 833 1369 638 210 631 113 521 691 1329 415 1282 705 416 47 579 709 1155 95 1376 1075 1034 747 1423 153 1005 721